Today's posts - Quoteworthy - Obamanalysis - Michelle O - Mark Steyn - Women - Children - Parenting - Education - Culture - Culture of death - Music - Sinatra - Books - Best of P&P - Twitter

When a society loses its memory, it descends inevitably into dementia. Mark Steyn
.

February 9, 2010

Blaming Rahm Emanuel for the failure of Obamacare

What has prevented the passage of Obamacare? Here's the blame it on Rahm explanation reported by Alexander Bolton of The Hill:

Democrats in Congress are holding White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel accountable for his part in the collapse of healthcare reform.

The emerging consensus among critics in both chambers is that Emanuel’s lack of Senate experience slowed President Barack Obama’s top domestic priority.

The share of the blame comes as cracks are beginning to show in Emanuel’s once-impregnable political armor. Last week he had to apologize after a report surfaced that he called liberal groups “retarded” in a private meeting.

While Emanuel has quelled that controversy by meeting with advocates for people with disabilities, on Capitol Hill he’s under fire for poor execution of the president’s healthcare agenda in the Senate.

"I think Rahm ran the play his boss called; once Obama called the play, Rahm did everything he could to pass it, scorched-earth and all that,” said a senior lawmaker, who added that Emanuel didn’t seek a broader base of Senate Republicans. “I think he did miscalculate the Senate. He did what he thought he had to do to win." [. . . ]

A liberal House Democrat who served with Emanuel during his entire career in Congress said: "I don't think the skills that are attributed to him — muscling things through — are well-suited to the Senate.

"The House is like an Australian-rules rugby match,” the lawmaker added. “The Senate is like a march at a men’s club in imperial Britain. They're a bunch of barons over there."
Brute force, indiscriminately applied, seems to be the modus operandi of this White House. No doubt Emanuel's heavy hand was at times a detriment to the cause. Other opinions on who botched what and how are presented in Bolton's piece, including a view that too much time was wasted on faux bipartisanship, and another that Obama didn't spend enough time promoting his pet project on the stump (though he seemed to do little else but campaign and speechify).

No mention is made of the fact that the content of each and every misbegotten, gargantuan piece of legislation crafted by Congress was solidly unpopular with the American people. And guess what -- now they're angry. Obama didn't see that train coming but he's going to jump out of the way now by morphing into a "populist," which consists of trying to trick Americans into thinking they're mad at someone else -- Bush, "obstructionist" Republicans, various "fatcats" and "special interests," "Washington," Rush, cable news and "the blogs" -- anyone but him. Good luck with that.

A few days ago I quoted from David Catron's piece on what went wrong with Obamacare. It's now ancient history by internet standards (Feb. 5) but we might refer back to it as the post-mortems roll out:

Wh0 Killed Obamacare? Obama did it himself, and here's how:
He has broken virtually every campaign promise he made concerning reform, presided over a series of shady back room deals, and treated the voters like an irritating group of poorly behaved and dull-witted children.
Read the rest.

*Updated to add another explanatory article about the failure of Obama's first year:
A fearsome foursome by Edward Luce

Linked at Michelle Malkin (buzzworthy) -- thanks!

Most recent posts here.

3 comments:

  1. Obama is the President so he must take responsibility for ignoring the American people and trying to force this monstrosity of a health care bill down our throats. Although, it doesn't seem like he's capable of taking responsibility for anything that goes wrong or for making the wrong decisions. He demonstrated Chicago thuggery at its worst. And, he didn't keep important campaign promises. This is worse than business as usual in Washington. It is the most corrupt administration ever!
    ReplyDelete
  2. Teresa... how quickly you forget.

    The Obama administration barely registers on the brass knuckle meter.

    "Flashback six years, and it was the Democrats asking [HHS actuary Richard] Foster to examine the Republicans’ proposal to create Part D, Medicare’s enormous prescription drug benefit that took effect in 2006. The Congressional Budget Office had estimated the cost of the proposal to be $395 billion over 10 years — just shy of the $400 billion authorized by the GOP’s budget bill — but Democrats also wanted Foster’s estimate, which was later revealed to be $534 billion.

    They didn’t get it. Instead, Thomas Scully, the Bush appointee who headed the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services at the time, screened all of Foster’s work to ensure that nothing got to Congress that might threaten the bill."

    You remember Medicare Part D, right? That'd be the unfunded initiative that Republicans rammed through Congress using vote extensions and buy-offs.

    -----
    Yes, health care legislation IS unpopular with the public.

    NOW - now that what was promised (affordable coverage for the uninsured- a viable public option - and restrictions on predatory industry practices) has been watered down to the point of being unrecognizable. What the GOP BS bullhorn didn't do - the co-opted members of the Senate did. You can blame Rahm, Obama or whoever you want - but the fact is the health care industry and the legislators they own (on both sides of the aisle) are on the verge of preserving the status quo that favors their continued profit - and preserves the original problem.

    Much is made of Scott Brown (and he is an undeniable kick in the teeth to Dem strategy) but the fact is the Dems would never have a solid 60 votes they could rely on. Look at Lieberman, or Nelson, or Landrieu - hell, the whole Blue Dog posse - an unbeatable majority was always a pipe dream. It's hard to figure out who is more contemptible - the GOP for its full stop obstructionism (and then complaining why nothing gets done) or the Dems in the senate who were genuinely releived when Scott Brown was elected - because he was an excuse for them to give up.

    The Medicare problem won't go away - and we've wasted a year. A triumph of Washingon interests over national needs. Hoo-rah.
    ReplyDelete